HVC vs TDK: Screw Terminal HV Ceramic Capacitor Performance Benchmark White Paper

Capacitor_Blog

HVC vs TDK: Screw Terminal HV Ceramic Capacitor Performance Benchmark White Paper

Views: ...

Abstract

This white paper presents a comprehensive technical and supply chain comparison between the two major options in HV bolt terminal ceramic capacitors — the industry incumbent TDK and the emerging high-performance alternative HVC. We evaluate core technical parameters, product reliability, dimensional compatibility, and supply chain cost. The data shows HVC holds significant advantages in voltage range (10-150KV, wider coverage), maximum capacitance (8000pF vs 2100pF), environmental compliance (lead-free N4700), and delivery lead time (60% reduction).

1. Introduction

High-voltage bolt terminal ceramic capacitors are a specialized type of HV ceramic capacitor widely used in medical imaging (CT, X-ray), power transformers, industrial NDT equipment, laser power supplies, and scientific instruments. These components must operate reliably at tens of thousands of volts while maintaining ultra-low dissipation factor, excellent temperature stability, and long-term reliability.

TDK has over 40 years of experience in this field, with products spanning the UHV, FHV, and FD series. However, constrained by its Class 2 ceramic material system (Y5S/Z5T) and traditional single-chip structure, TDK's voltage ceiling sits at 50KV with a maximum capacitance of just 2100pF. Additionally, the Y5S dielectric contains lead (though RoHS-exempted), posing a potential risk as global environmental regulations tighten.

This white paper presents detailed comparative data to demonstrate how HVC delivers a more resilient solution without compromising performance.

2. Technical Background: Why Ceramic Material and HV Design Matter

2.1 Ceramic Dielectric Classification

The core performance of HV ceramic capacitors depends on dielectric material selection:

  • Class 1 Ceramics (e.g. N4700, NP0): Lower dielectric constant but excellent temperature stability (near-linear TCC) and ultra-low dissipation factor (D.F. < 0.002), suitable for high-frequency resonant and precision applications.
  • Class 2 Ceramics (e.g. Y5S, Z5T, Y5P): Higher dielectric constant but poorer temperature stability, with dissipation factor varying significantly with temperature and voltage. Y5S and similar leaded formulations can approach N4700 D.F. levels but fall under RoHS exemptions, raising long-term compliance uncertainty.

2.2 Technology Route Comparison

  • TDK: Y5S/Z5T Class 2 ceramic + silver electrode + single-chip structure. Mature performance but leaded formulation, constrained by 60mm package mold limits.
  • HVC: N4700 Class 1 ceramic + copper electrode + dual-chip series/parallel structure. Through material upgrade and structural innovation, HVC achieves performance metrics exceeding TDK at industrial-grade cost.

3. Core Technical Parameter Comparison

ParameterTDK SpecHVC SpecAssessment
Voltage Range20KV ~ 50KV10KV ~ 150KVHVC covers 3x range
Max Capacitance (Standard)2100pF (50KV)8000pF (50KV)HVC 3.8x larger
Ceramic Material TypeY5S, Z5T, Y5P (Class 2)N4700 (Class 1)HVC Class 1 more stable
Lead ContentY5S contains lead (RoHS exempt)Lead-freeHVC fully RoHS compliant
Electrode ProcessSilver platingCopper electrode platingHVC superior migration resistance
Internal StructureTraditional single chipDual-chip series/parallelHVC breaks physical limits
Standard Lead Time12-16 weeks4-6 weeksHVC 3x faster
Cost Index100% (baseline)50-80%HVC 20-50% lower

4. Complete Series Quick Selection Guide

The following tables cover all standard models across TDK's UHV, FHV, TSF and FD series — 53 models with corresponding HVC replacement models. HVC uses N4700 Class 1 ceramic (lead-free, lower dissipation factor) to upgrade TDK's original Y5S/Z5T/Y5P Class 2 materials.

TSF & FD Series (AC Rated)

TDK ModelSpec (Voltage/Cap)TDK MaterialHVC ReplacementHVC Material (Upgrade)
TSF-40C20KVAC, 1080pFZ5THVCT8G-20KVAC-DL40-1081KN4700
TSF-3020KVAC, 400pFZ5THVCT8G-20KVAC-DL30-401KN4700
FD-9A10KVAC, 100pFY5PHVCT8G-10KVAC-DL30-101KN4700
FD-10A / FD-10AU10KVAC, 250pFY5PHVCT8G-10KVAC-DL30-251KN4700
FD-11A / FD-11AU10KVAC, 500pFY5PHVCT8G-10KVAC-DL30-501KN4700
FD-12A / FD-12AU10KVAC, 1000pFY5PHVCT8G-10KVAC-DL40-102KN4700
FD-16A / FD-16AU13KVAC, 250pFY5PHVCT8G-13KVAC-DL30-251KN4700
FD-18A / FD-18AU13KVAC, 500pFY5PHVCT8G-13KVAC-DL30-501KN4700
FD-20A13KVAC, 1000pFY5PHVCT8G-13KVAC-DL50-102KN4700
FD-22A20KVAC, 250pFY5PHVCT8G-20KVAC-DL30-251KN4700
FD-24A20KVAC, 500pFY5PHVCT8G-20KVAC-DL40-501KN4700
FD-33A25KVAC, 250pFY5PHVCT8G-25KVAC-DL30-251KN4700
FD-36A25KVAC, 500pFY5PHVCT8G-25KVAC-DL50-501KN4700

FHV Series (DC Molded)

TDK ModelSpec (Voltage/Cap)TDK MaterialHVC ReplacementHVC Material (Upgrade)
FHV-153AN15KVDC, 7000pFY5SHVCT8G-15KV-DL60-702KN4700
FHV-1AN20KVDC, 1700pFY5SHVCT8G-20KV-DL40-172KN4700
FHV-2AN20KVDC, 3000pFY5SHVCT8G-20KV-DL50-302KN4700
FHV-3AN20KVDC, 5200pFY5SHVCT8G-20KV-DL60-522KN4700
FHV-4AN30KVDC, 1200pFY5SHVCT8G-30KV-DL40-122KN4700
FHV-5AN30KVDC, 2100pFY5SHVCT8G-30KV-DL50-212KN4700
FHV-6AN30KVDC, 3500pFY5SHVCT8G-30KV-DL60-352KN4700
FHV-7AN40KVDC, 850pFY5SHVCT8G-40KV-DL40-851KN4700
FHV-8AN40KVDC, 1500pFY5SHVCT8G-40KV-DL50-152KN4700
FHV-9AN40KVDC, 2600pFY5SHVCT8G-40KV-DL60-262KN4700
FHV-10AN50KVDC, 700pFY5SHVCT8G-50KV-DL40-701KN4700
FHV-11AN50KVDC, 1300pFY5SHVCT8G-50KV-DL50-132KN4700
FHV-12AN50KVDC, 2100pFY5SHVCT8G-50KV-DL60-212KN4700

UHV Series (Ultra-High Voltage Bolt Terminal)

TDK ModelSpec (Voltage/Cap)TDK MaterialHVC ReplacementHVC Material (Upgrade)
20KV Grade
UHV-221A20KVDC, 200pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL30-201KN4700
UHV-222A20KVDC, 400pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL30-401KN4700
UHV-223A20KVDC, 700pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL30-701KN4700
UHV-224A20KVDC, 1000pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL30-102KN4700
UHV-1A20KVDC, 1400pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL40-142KN4700
UHV-2A20KVDC, 2500pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL50-252KN4700
UHV-3A20KVDC, 4000pFZ5THVCT8G-20KV-DL60-402KN4700
30KV Grade
UHV-231A30KVDC, 200pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL30-201KN4700
UHV-232A30KVDC, 400pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL30-401KN4700
UHV-233A30KVDC, 700pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL30-701KN4700
UHV-4A30KVDC, 940pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL40-941KN4700
UHV-5A30KVDC, 1700pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL50-172KN4700
UHV-6A30KVDC, 2700pFZ5THVCT8G-30KV-DL60-272KN4700
40KV Grade
UHV-241A40KVDC, 100pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL30-101KN4700
UHV-242A40KVDC, 200pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL30-201KN4700
UHV-243A40KVDC, 400pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL30-401KN4700
UHV-7A40KVDC, 700pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL40-701KN4700
UHV-8A40KVDC, 1300pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL50-132KN4700
UHV-9A40KVDC, 2000pFZ5THVCT8G-40KV-DL60-202KN4700
50KV Grade
UHV-251A50KVDC, 100pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL30-101KN4700
UHV-252A50KVDC, 200pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL30-201KN4700
UHV-253A50KVDC, 400pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL40-401KN4700
UHV-10A50KVDC, 560pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL40-561KN4700
UHV-11A50KVDC, 1000pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL50-102KN4700
UHV-12A50KVDC, 1700pFZ5THVCT8G-50KV-DL60-172KN4700

5. HVC HVCT8G Part Number Decoder

HVCT8G-[Voltage]-[Size Code]-[Capacitance Code]
FieldMeaningExample
HVCT8GDoorknob capacitor series prefixHVCT8G-20KV-DL30-201K
Voltage20KV / 30KV / 40KV / 50KV / 20KVAC etc.30KV
DL30-60Diameter code: DL30=30mm, DL40=40mm, DL50=50mm, DL60=60mmDL40
Capacitance Code201=200pF, 102=1000pF, 702=7000pF941K
KTolerance ±10%K

6. Typical Replacement Cases

TDK P/NHVC ReplacementKey Technology Upgrade
UHV-4A 30KV 940pFHVCT8G-30KV-DL40-941KZ5T→N4700 material upgrade, copper electrode
FHV-3AN 20KV 5200pFHVCT8G-20KV-DL60-522KY5S(leaded)→N4700(lead-free) upgrade
FD-12A 10KVAC 1000pFHVCT8G-10KVAC-DL40-102KY5P→N4700, superior HF performance

7. Reliability Test Data

Addressing the lifetime concerns critical to industrial and medical applications, HVC conducted rigorous testing per IEC 60384 standards:

7.1 Dielectric Withstanding Voltage Test

  • Condition: 1.5x rated voltage applied for 60 seconds.
  • Result: Sample n=100, HVC HVCT8G series 100% passed — no flashover or breakdown.

7.2 High-Temperature Aging Test (1000 hours)

  • Condition: +85℃ ambient temperature, rated voltage applied.
Monitored ParameterTDK ReferenceHVC MeasuredStandard Requirement
Capacitance Change (ΔC/C)Typical ±8%< ±5%< ±10%
Insulation Resistance (IR)> 1000MΩ> 5000MΩ> 1000MΩ
Appearance IntegrityNo anomalyNo anomalyNo cracks / no flashover

7.3 Temperature Cycling Test

  • Condition: -55℃ to +125℃, 100 cycles.
  • Result: No mechanical damage, capacitance change < ±3%.

8. Mechanical Compatibility Verification

HVC HVCT8G series products are designed to strictly follow TDK UHV/FHV physical dimension standards, ensuring Form-Fit-Function (3F) level drop-in replacement.

DimensionTDK Spec (UHV-4A)HVC Spec (HVCT8G-30KV-DL40-941K)Compatibility
Body Diameter40mm40mm (DL40)Identical
Bolt SpacingM6 standardM6 standardFully compatible
Overall Height60mm (typical)60mm (typical)Fully compatible
Mounting TypeScrew terminalScrew terminalIdentical

9. Supply Chain & Business Value Analysis

Evaluation DimensionTDK (Baseline)HVC (Optimized)Customer Benefit
Standard Lead Time12-16 weeks4-6 weeks3x faster turnaround
Custom Lead Time20-24 weeks6-8 weeksSignificantly faster R&D iteration
Cost Index100%50-80%20-50% BOM cost reduction
MOQ100 pcs50 pcsLower inventory capital commitment

10. Conclusion & Selection Recommendations

Based on technical performance, reliability data, and supply chain capability, the HVC HVCT8G series has demonstrated its viability and superiority as a replacement for TDK HV ceramic capacitors.

Selection Recommendations:

  • Recommended HVC deployment: All medical, industrial, and power electronics projects pursuing supply chain security (dual-source strategy), cost optimization, and fast delivery.
  • Material upgrade scenario: For existing TDK Y5S (leaded) designs, HVC N4700 provides a lead-free upgrade path.
  • Performance breakthrough scenario: For applications requiring >50KV voltage or >2100pF capacitance, HVC is currently the only mature alternative solution.

Start Replacement Verification

HVC offers free samples and technical support, with specification confirmation available within 48 hours.

© HVC Capacitor Manufacturing Co., Ltd. TDK® is a registered trademark of TDK Corporation. This document is for technical comparison purposes only and does not imply affiliation with or endorsement by the trademark holder.

News

CONTACT US

Contact: Sales Department

Phone: +86 13689553728

Tel: +86-755-61167757

Email: sales@hv-caps.com

Add: 9B2, TianXiang Building, Tianan Cyber Park , Futian, Shenzhen, P. R. C